Tracking delivery
Government assurances committees explained
Short answer
- Lok Sabha committee first nominated
- 1 December 1953 3
- Rajya Sabha committee first constituted
- 1 July 1972 3
- Time to fulfil an assurance in India
- Three months from the date of the assurance 1
- Indian monitoring system
- Online Assurances Monitoring System (OAMS) 1
- Ghana committee size
- 17 members, chaired from the opposition 8
- Zambia committee size
- Eight members, quorum of four 6
What counts as an assurance
India's Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs describes assurances as statements by ministers on the floor of the House in the form of promises, undertakings or similar expressions, often made when information is not yet to hand 3. It keeps a standard list of expressions that count as assurances and says other remarks may be treated as assurances on the basis of the context 3.
The Lok Sabha committee's working manual, quoted in its reports, says an assurance arises when a minister gives an undertaking that involves further action by the government in reporting back to the House 1. The Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs extracts these from the proceedings and sends them to the department concerned through OAMS, normally within 20 working days 1.
How the Indian committees work
The Lok Sabha committee is nominated by the Speaker and was first nominated on 1 December 1953 3. The Rajya Sabha committee was first constituted on 1 July 1972 3. The committee manual links the Lok Sabha committee to Lok Sabha Rules 323 and 324 and the Rajya Sabha committee to Rajya Sabha Rule 211-A 1.
Both committees scrutinise the assurances, promises and undertakings given by ministers and report on how far they have been implemented and whether this happened within the minimum time necessary 3. The Lok Sabha committee for 2020-21 listed a Chairperson and 14 other members 2.
- Deadline: an assurance given in either House must be fulfilled within three months 1.
- Extension: the department asks for more time as soon as the need becomes apparent, with reasons and the extra time needed, through OAMS 1.
- Dropping: a department that cannot implement an assurance must ask the committee to drop it, normally within a week, with prior approval of the minister 1.
- Requests sent outside OAMS are not entertained under any circumstances, according to the committee manual 1.
- The committee's decisions on these requests are treated as final 3.
What a committee report shows
Lok Sabha committee reports record the status of each assurance. The Eighty-Fifth Report of the 17th Lok Sabha, adopted on 25 July 2023, reviewed assurances pending with the Legislative Department of the Ministry of Law and Justice 1.
| Item in the Eighty-Fifth Report | Figure |
|---|---|
| Assurances pending with the department 1 | 39, of which 4 dated from the 15th Lok Sabha, 17 from the 16th and 18 from the 17th 1 |
| Taken up for oral evidence on 16 January 2023 1 | 26 1 |
| Implemented, with reports laid on 8 February 2023 1 | 8 1 |
| Dropped with the committee's consent 1 | 13 1 |
| Still unfulfilled 1 | 5 1 |
When a committee refuses to drop an assurance
The committee can turn down a request to drop. Its Eighteenth Report of the 17th Lok Sabha, dated February 2021, is titled Requests for Dropping of Assurances (Not Acceded to) 2. It listed an assurance from an unstarred question of 8 January 2019 on comments on a Law Commission report, with the Ministry of Home Affairs, and one from a starred question of 14 December 2011 with the Ministry of Coal 2.
Indian state assemblies
State legislatures in India run their own committees. In Haryana, Rule 243 of the assembly rules sets the committee's functions and Rule 244 caps it at nine members nominated by the Speaker for one year 5. The Kerala Niyamasabha committee has no more than nine members as well, and ministers cannot sit on it 4. Kerala's Rule 258 says periodical statements showing reasons for delay are laid on the Table once in six months 4.
Committees in other parliaments
The Kenya committee may propose sanctions against a Cabinet Secretary who fails to report on implementation without justifiable reasons, according to its parliament page 7.
| Parliament | Committee | Basis and mandate |
|---|---|---|
| Zambia 6 | Committee on Government Assurances 6 | Standing Order No. 155(2). Scrutinises assurances and undertakings made by Cabinet Ministers and Deputy Ministers on the floor of the House 6 |
| Ghana 8 | Committee on Assurances 8 | Monitors the execution of all assurances, promises and undertakings made to Parliament and reports to the House 8 |
| Kenya, National Assembly 7 | Committee on Implementation 7 | Standing Order 209. Scrutinises House resolutions, petitions and undertakings given by the National Executive 7 |
| Uganda 9 | Government Assurance and Implementation Committee 9 | Rule 185 sets its functions and Rule 186 covers withdrawal of an assurance, in rules dated 18 February 2025 9 |
Common questions
How long does an Indian ministry have to fulfil an assurance?
Three months from the date of the assurance. The committee can grant an extension 1.
Can an assurance be cancelled?
A ministry can ask the committee to drop it with reasons. The committee can agree or refuse 1,2.
Who picks the members of the Lok Sabha committee?
The Speaker nominates the committee 3.
Does Kenya have an assurances committee?
The National Assembly's Committee on Implementation tracks undertakings given by the National Executive 7.
Can ministers sit on the committee?
Not in Kerala. A member who becomes a minister leaves the committee from the date of appointment 4.
Rules and charges change. Check the official source linked on this page before you pay or travel. Spotted an error? Email hello@statementsofrecord.com.
Sources
- Lok Sabha Secretariat: Committee on Government Assurances (2022-2023), Eighty-Fifth Report, Review of Pending Assurances Pertaining to the Ministry of Law and Justice (Legislative Department) (July 2023)
- Lok Sabha Secretariat: Committee on Government Assurances (2020-2021), Eighteenth Report, Requests for Dropping of Assurances (Not Acceded to) (February 2021)
- Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs: Monitoring Assurances, Handbook on the Working of Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs
- Kerala Legislative Assembly: Committee on Government Assurances, Introduction
- Haryana Vidhan Sabha: Committee on Government Assurances
- National Assembly of Zambia: Committee on Government Assurances
- Parliament of Kenya: Committee on Implementation (12 February 2015)
- Parliament of Ghana: Committee on Assurances
- Parliament of Uganda: The Rules of Procedure of the Parliament of Uganda, Statutory Instruments 2025 No. 43
Related
- Official commitment trackers compared
How India's OAMS, Kenya's and Ghana's committees, the NDC Registry, UN commitment platforms and OGP's reporting mechanism track delivery of promises.
- How public commitments are recorded
Where public commitments are officially recorded: parliamentary assurances, written statements, NDC and UN registries, OGP plans and company filings.
- How official positions change on the record
Formal routes for changing a recorded commitment: correcting Parliament, dropping an assurance, adjusting an NDC, leaving a treaty, updating a forecast.
- Written ministerial statements explained
How UK ministers put announcements on the parliamentary record in writing, where the statements are published and how the Australian Senate handles them.